Jewelry Under $250

Solid Cable Chain 1.5mm Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 3"

from $59.88

Sterling Silver St. Christopher Soccer Medal Pendant(30X17MM)

$51.88 $82.88

Sterling Silver Small Mother and Child Pendant

$65.88 $112.99

Men's Stainless Steel Rope Chain with Lobster Clasp 30"

$109.88 $181.99

Men's Brushed Finish Open Cross Pendant Necklace , Stainless Steel, 22"

$179.88 $196.88

Engraved Buffalo Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$81.88 $129.88

Amethyst, Aquamarine and Ruby Pointed Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$229.88

Adjustable Box Chain .75mm Sterling Silver, 22''

$55.88 $96.88

14k Yellow Gold 1mm Solid Box Chain, Extender Safety Chain, 1.25"

from $129.88

1.5mm 14k Yellow Gold Solid Cable Chain Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

$86.88 $133.99

1.5mm 14k Yellow Gold Rope Chain Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

$77.88 $109.99

1.5mm 14k White Gold Hollow Belcher Rolo Chain Necklace Extender and Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

1.50mm Sterling Silver Solid Cable Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

$59.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver Synthetic Amethyst February Birthstone Bypass Ring, 12k Green and Rose Black Hills Gold

from $119.88

Dakota Rose Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 7

$213.88 $335.88

Stainless Steel Grooved and Beaded 6mm Comfort-Fit Comfort-Fit Dome Band, Size 7

$99.89 $116.88

Blue Topaz and Citrine Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 11.25

$199.88 $300.88

Womens Sterling Silver Crucifix Chastity Ring, Size 8

$63.88 $126.99

US Air Force Halo Cross Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 24"

$129.88 $167.88

Two Leaf Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88 $227.88

Tree of Life Rose Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88

Sterling Silver Twins Family Pendant of The Mother and Child Collection

$89.88 $117.99

Sterling Silver St. Christopher Medal for Baseball Players Necklace, 24" (24.5x15.5 MM)

$123.88 $151.88

Sterling Silver Saint Jude Thaddeus Medal (26X20MM)

$89.88 $116.88

Sterling Silver Rosary Ring, Size 8

$99.88 $102.99

Sterling Silver Crisis Pregnancy Center Cross Pendant Necklace 18"

Sold out

Star of Bethlehem Diamond Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (.25 Ct, G-H Color,SI1 Clarity)

Sold out

Sliding Treble Clef Musical Note Sterling Silver Pendant

$66.88 $106.88

Rounded Edge Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (34.8X18.6MM)

$59.88 $99.88

Platinum Initial Letter 'S' Stud Earring (Single Earring)

$209.88 $327.88

Pheasant in Flight Tie Tack, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$189.88

Petite Black Hills Gold Grape Leaf Stud Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Rose and Mint-Green Gold

$189.88 $219.88

Men's Polished Stainless Steel Leather Strap Snake Bracelet, 8.25"

$151.88 $238.88

Leaf and Grape Cluster Cocktail Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

from $94.88

Infinity Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$129.88 $165.88

Heart Dolphin Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$92.88 $167.88

Hammered Finish Flip Flop Sandal Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$129.88

Halo Cross Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$149.88 $226.88

Grey Titanium with Black Enamel Fleur De Lis Round Cuff Links,19MM

$142.88 $225.88

Granulated Bead Border, Scrollwork Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 8.25

$189.88 $195.88

Graduated CZ with Scrollwork Butterfly Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 9

$189.88 $232.88

Gold-Plated Sterling Silver University Of Virginia Crest Round Cuff Links, 15MM

Sold out

Gold-Plated Sterling Silver Southern Methodist University Crest Cuff Links, 15MM

$123.88 $195.88

Genuine Idaho Garnet Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$109.88 $152.88

Engraved Trim Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$149.88 $214.88

Embossed Flowers Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$159.88 $197.88

Elk Oval Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$219.88

Edward Mirell Titanium Cable and 18k Gold Rivets Pendant Necklace, 20"

Sold out

Edward Mirell Titanium Blue Anodized Wide Center 10mm Grooved Band

$171.88 $270.88

Edward Mirell Black Titanium Blue Anodized Wide Center 10mm Band

$245.88 $385.88

Edward Mirell Black Titanium and Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 20"

Sold out

Dove Olive Branch Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$139.88 $144.88

Diamond Letter 'A' Initial Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 18" (.005 Ct, GH Color, I2 Clarity)

$116.88

Ave 369 Marquise Synthetic Emerald May Birthstone Wrap Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Black Hills Gold

from $189.88

Black Epoxy Inlay Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (24X16MM)

$139.88 $145.88

Adjustable Cable Chain .95mm Sterling Silver, 22''

$53.88 $92.88

Ave 369 6-Stone CZ Dragonfly Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$219.88

3.2 mm Stainless Steel Curb Chain, 18"

from $51.88

14k Yellow Gold St. John Medal Pendant (21X19MM)

$232.88 $365.88

14k Yellow Gold Round San Juan de Los Lagos Medal (15 MM)

from $229.88

Ave 369 14k Yellow Gold 4-Way Cross Medal Pendant (29x19MM)

$209.88

14k Yellow Gold 1.3mm Diamond-Cut Box Chain, Extender Safety Chain, 1.25"

from $143.88

10k Yellow Gold Lady of Mount Carmel Framed Enamel Pendant (25.75x25.75 MM)

Sold out

1.5mm Sterling Silver Solid Cable Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 3"

$59.88

1 mm Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Diamond Cut Cable Bracelet, 7"

from $99.88

Twinkling Diamond Teardrop Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18" (.1 Ct)

$249.88 $451.88

Cross with Cowboy Boot Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$169.88 $171.88

Purple Jade Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$209.88 $265.88

Trillion-Cut Blue Sapphire Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$239.88

Two-Tone Feather Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$249.88

Dome Heart Locket Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$229.88 $289.88

Ave 369 Black Powder Coat with Gold Trim and Leaves Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$229.88

Ave 369 10k Yellow Gold Mason's Emblem Onyx Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

from $239.88

Tree of Life Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold, 18''

$199.88 $207.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (for HER) Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$149.88 $160.88

Church Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold, 18''

$149.88

Onyx Free Mason's Signet Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

$219.88 $387.88

Ave 369 Garnet Pear Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$169.88

Garnet Pear Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$169.88 $210.88

Fancy Cut-Out Leaf Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

from $199.88

Fancy Cut-Out Leaf Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 11

$199.88 $203.88

Womens Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold, 12k Pink Gold, 5 Stones Ring, Sizes 4, 4.5, 5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9

$249.88 $277.99

Gold Box Elder Burl Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $249.88

Matte Titanium 8mm Comfort-Fit Bloodwood Band

$229.88 $485.88

Matte Titanium 8mm Comfort-Fit Bloodwood Band and Sizing Ring, Size, 9

$229.88 $501.88

Hammered 7mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

from $219.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 10mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band

from $229.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 10mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 9

$229.88 $421.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 10mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 8

$229.88 $421.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 7mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band

from $229.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 7mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 5.5

$229.88 $421.88

Green Box Elder Burl Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

$249.88 $501.88

Ruby Redwood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

from $229.88

Ruby Redwood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 11

$229.88 $501.88

Kauri Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

from $229.88

Engraved Graphic Line Pattern 7mm Comfort-Fit Domed Wedding Band, Size 10

$149.88 $591.88

Ebony Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Polished Titanium Ring

from $229.88

Ebony Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Polished Titanium Ring, Size 12.5

$229.88 $422.88

Rowan Wood Inlay 6mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Good Luck Ring

$249.88 $422.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Ring

from $249.88

Concrete Inlay 6mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Ring

from $229.88

Concrete Inlay 6mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Ring, Size 9

$229.88 $512.88

Black Enamel Pinstripes 8mm Comfort Fit Beveled Titanium Wedding Band

$169.88 $582.88

Black Enamel Pinstripes 8mm Comfort Fit Beveled Titanium Wedding Band, Size 14.25

$229.88 $582.88

Black Enamel Pinstripes 8mm Comfort Fit Beveled Titanium Wedding Band, Size 7.75

$169.88 $582.88

Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M13.5-F5.5

$249.88 $422.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set

$189.88 $422.88

Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M8.5-F4

$189.88 $422.88

Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M13.5-F9

$249.88 $422.88

Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M8-F6

$189.88 $422.88

Mirror Finish Titanium, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M9.5-F8.5

$189.88 $422.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 9

$219.88 $652.88

Interchangeable Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Brushed Titanium Ring, Size 11.25

from $229.88

Interchangeable Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Brushed Titanium Ring, Size 12.75

$229.88 $542.88

Bocote Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Ring

from $249.88

Bocote Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Ring, Size 12

$249.88 $542.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Maple Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $219.88

Maple Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8

$219.88 $652.88

Buckeye Burl Wood 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Sold out

Buckeye Burl Wood 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Wedding Band, Size 12.25

Sold out

Titanium, Redwood Pinstripe, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M9-F7.5

$219.88 $782.88

Titanium, Redwood Pinstripe, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M9-F7

$219.88 $782.88

Titanium, Redwood Pinstripe, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M12.5-F5.5

$219.88 $782.88

Titanium, Redwood Pinstripe, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M10-F4

from $219.88

Titanium, Redwood Pinstripe, His and Hers Wedding Band Set, M8-F4

$219.88 $782.88

Interchangeable Wood Ring with Peridot Burl Wood Inlay 8 mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band

from $219.88

Bloodwood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $249.88

14k White Gold August CZ Birthstone Ring, Size 3

Sold out

Bloodwood 8mm Matte Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 5

$249.88 $439.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Bethlehem Olive Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $249.88

Bethlehem Olive Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 4.25

$249.88 $652.88

Desert Ironwood 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Desert Ironwood 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 9.5

$219.88 $652.88

Macassar Ebony Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Ring

from $219.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Koa Wood Inlay 12mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring

from $219.88

Marble Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Marble Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.75

$219.88 $652.88

Leopardwood 8mm Comfort-Fit Domed Titanium Band

from $249.88

Buckeye Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $229.88

Buckeye Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Wedding Band, Size 9.5

$229.88 $542.88

Olive Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Wedding Band, Size 10

from $249.88

Gold Box Elder Burl Wood Inlay 6mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Band, Size 10

from $249.88

Bamboo Wood 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13

from $219.88

Rosewood Box with Brass Clock and Brass Compass (4.25x4.25IN)

$89.88

Canary Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 12.75

from $219.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Ironwood Flat Ring 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $219.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Ironwood Flat Ring 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 4.25

$219.88 $652.88

Snakewood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Snakewood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5.5

$219.88 $652.88

Black Ash Burl Wood 6mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Black Ash Burl Wood 6mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5.25

$219.88 $652.88

Interchangeable Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band , Size 10

from $219.88

Men's Titanium Redwood 10mm Comfort-Fit Band, Handmade, Interchangeable, Size 7.5

$219.88 $482.88

Peruvian Ipe Wood 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Peruvian Ipe Wood 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band, Size 6

$219.88 $482.88

Bloodwood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Ring, Size 6.25

$249.88 $350.88

Bloodwood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Ring, Size 8.75

$249.88 $350.88

Bamboo Wood Stripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Ring

from $219.88

Red Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Dark Green Burl 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 13.75

from $219.88

Ave 369 Created Opal Heart Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Gold Pink and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $199.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver 1.65 Ct Sky Blue Topaz and Diamond Pendant Necklace 18 Inches (.012 Ctw, HJ, I3)

$179.88

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Dog Tag Pendant

$79.88

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Key Chain

$59.88

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Bracelet 8.75 Inches

$89.88

Ave 369 Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold 1mm Solid Cable Chain Necklace Extender and Safety Chain

from $89.88

Ave 369 'What Would Jesus Do' 14k Yellow Gold Prayer Ring

from $169.88

Ave 369 'Unblossomed Rose' 14k Yellow Gold Chastity Ring

$209.88

Ave 369 'Jesus I Trust In You' 14k Yellow Gold Prayer Ring

from $209.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver Amethyst and Diamond Double Hearts Ring in Black Hills Gold

from $179.88

Ruby Redwood Burl 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.5

$229.88 $391.88

Titanium Gypsy-Set CZ 3.75mm Ribbed Comfort-Fit Band

$101.88 $126.88

Black Ti Collection Black Titanium Domed Textured Lines 6mm Domed Wedding Band, Size 13

$227.88 $322.88

5.75mm Sterling Silver Scroll Design Fashion Band, Size 8

Sold out

Grooved Round Edged 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13

$126.88 $201.88

Titanium Satin Concave 6mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 12.5

$92.88 $116.88

Men's Cross Ring, Sterling Silver, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 12.25

$219.88 $225.88

Men's Cobalt 6mm High Polished Comfort Fit Band,Size 11

Sold out

Titanium Precision Diamond-Cut Design 8mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 10.5

$92.88 $116.88

On sale

Flat Profile Solid Titanium 8mm Comfort-Fit Polished Band, Size 14

$191.88 $301.88

Leaf and Grape Cluster Cocktail Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 6.5

$94.88 $149.88

Grey Titanium, Black IP 8mm Wedding Band, Size 9.5

$92.88 $159.88

Sold out

Heart with Cross Sterling Silver Slim Profile Ring, Size 8.25

Sold out

1 mm Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Diamond Cut Cable Chain, 18"

Sold out

White Freshwater Cultured Pearl Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver (6.5-7mm) Size 7.75

Sold out

Titanium Gypsy-Set CZ 3.75mm Ribbed Comfort-Fit Band Size 11

Sold out

Lab Created Blue Spinel September Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 7.25

$129.88 $147.88

Inverted Grooved 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 6.5

$126.88 $201.88

Satin Titanium 7mm Comfort-Fit Beveled Edge Wedding Band, Size 10.5

$191.88 $301.88

Titanium, Yellow IP Edged Gypsy-Set CZ 5mm Flat Comfort-Fit Band

$101.88 $126.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) 8mm Comfort Fit Satin Black Tungsten Band, Size 13

$96.88 $236.88

Brushed Titanium 10mm Grooved Comfort-Fit Band, Size 9.5

$92.88 $116.88

Red Grooved Pinstripe 5mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.5

$236.88 $372.88

Titanium 4mm Comfort-Fit Flat Band, Size 9.5

$92.88 $116.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver Six Leaf CZ Dragonfly Bypass Ring, 12k Rose and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Size 7.75

$239.88 $395.88

Stainless Steel 2.5mm Bismark Chain, 20"

$74.88 $94.88

Diamond-Cut Leaf Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 8

$199.88

Edward Mirell Brushed Titanium Blue Topaz 4mm Wedding Band, Size 10

$171.88 $270.88