Jewelry Under $500

Ave 369 Rosebud Bypass Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Pink and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $323.88

Ave 369 Marquise Garnet Wrap Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

$443.88

Sterling Silver St. Christopher Soccer Medal Pendant(30X17MM)

$131.88

Sterling Silver Small Mother and Child Pendant

$143.88

Men's Stainless Steel Rope Chain with Lobster Clasp 30"

Sold out

Men's Titanium 5mm Black Titanium Memory Cable Link Bracelet, 8"

Sold out

Men's Brushed Finish Open Cross Pendant Necklace , Stainless Steel, 22"

$215.88

Engraved Buffalo Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$98.88 $129.88

Amethyst, Aquamarine and Ruby Pointed Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$275.88

Adjustable Box Chain .75mm Sterling Silver, 22''

$67.88 $96.88

14k Yellow Gold, 14k White Gold Two-Tone Crucifix Pendant

$419.88 $435.99

14k Yellow Gold 2.5mm Rope Extender Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold 2.4mm Wheat Chain Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold 1mm Solid Box Chain, Extender Safety Chain, 1.25"

Sold out

14k White Gold Round St. Andrew Medal (15 MM)

from $431.88

14k White Gold Engraved Cross Pendant (24x16 MM)

Sold out

1.5mm 14k Yellow Gold Solid Cable Chain Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

1.5mm 14k Yellow Gold Rope Chain Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

Solid Cable Chain 1.5mm Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 3"

Sold out

1.5mm 14k White Gold Hollow Belcher Rolo Chain Necklace Extender and Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

1.50mm Sterling Silver Solid Cable Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 2.25"

Sold out

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver Synthetic Amethyst February Birthstone Bypass Ring, 12k Green and Rose Black Hills Gold

from $143.88

Men's Cross Ring, Sterling Silver, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 12.25

$287.88

Dakota Rose Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 7

$256.88 $335.88

Double Open Heart Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$319.88 $399.88

Stainless Steel Grooved and Beaded 6mm Comfort-Fit Comfort-Fit Dome Band, Size 7

$119.88

Ave 369 10k Yellow Gold, Marquise Mystic Fire Topaz Wrap Ring, 12k Rose and Green Gold Black Hills Gold

$443.88

Blue Topaz and Citrine Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 11.25

$239.88 $300.88

Womens Sterling Silver Crucifix Chastity Ring, Size 8

Sold out

14K White Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross Pendant (4.5-5.0 MM)

Sold out

US Navy Halo Cross Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 24

$215.88

US Air Force Halo Cross Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 24"

$155.88 $167.88

Two-Tone 3D Celtic Crucifix 14k Yellow and White Gold Pendant (32X21MM)

Sold out

Two Leaf Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$227.88

Tree of Life Rose Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$227.88

Teardrop Onyx Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$455.88 $471.88

Sterling Silver Twins Family Pendant of The Mother and Child Collection

Sold out

Sterling Silver St. Christopher Medal for Baseball Players Necklace, 24" (24.5x15.5 MM)

Sold out

Sterling Silver Saint Jude Thaddeus Medal (26X20MM)

$143.88

Sterling Silver Saint Anthony Medal (35X20MM)

$143.88

Sterling Silver Rosary Ring, Size 8

$119.88

Sterling Silver Miraculous Medal Pendant (24X13 MM)

$131.88

Sterling Silver Crisis Pregnancy Center Cross Pendant Necklace 18"

Sold out

Sterling Silver Antiqued Saint Gerard Medal Charm Pendant (22X16 MM)

$107.88 $109.88

Star of Bethlehem Diamond Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (.25 Ct, G-H Color,SI1 Clarity)

Sold out

Stainless Steel Antiqued Miraculous Medal Necklace, 22" (40.13X26.31MM)

Sold out

Sliding Treble Clef Musical Note Sterling Silver Pendant

$80.88 $106.88

Satin Black Titanium Center 9mm Comfort Fit Band

$215.88 $277.88

Rounded Edge Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (34.8X18.6MM)

$71.88 $99.88

Rosary Necklace with Fluted Beads, Sterling Silver, 37"

Sold out

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver, Bowling Green, State University Crest Cuff Links, 15MM

Sold out

Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Four Way Cross Medal Pendant (30X25MM)

$479.88

Red Cloisonne Rosary Beads, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Platinum Initial Letter 'S' Stud Earring (Single Earring)

Sold out

Platinum Emerald Inset Cross Gold Pendant (22.65x11.4MM)

Sold out

Pheasant in Flight Tie Tack, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$227.88

Petite Black Hills Gold Grape Leaf Stud Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Rose and Mint-Green Gold

$227.88

Oval Mystic Fire Topaz Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$311.88 $347.88

Mens Large Stainless Steel Diamond Uptown Cross Pendant Necklace, 30" by Black and Blue Jewelry Co NY

Sold out

Men's Templar Collection Gray Titanium Faceted Edge Cuff Bracelet (14MM)

Sold out

Men's Stainless Steel 10mm Spiga Wheat Chain Bracelet, 9.5 Inches

$131.88

Men's Black Titanium, Black Titanium Memory Cable .14 Ctw Black Spinel 13mm Cuff Bracelet, 8"

Sold out

Leaf and Grape Cluster Cocktail Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

from $113.88

Infinity Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

Sold out

Hoop Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

$299.88

Heart Dolphin Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

Sold out

Hammered Finish Flip Flop Sandal Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$155.88

Halo Cross Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

Sold out

Grey Titanium with Black Enamel Fleur De Lis Round Cuff Links,19MM

Sold out

Granulated Bead Border, Scrollwork Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 8.25

$227.88

Graduated CZ with Scrollwork Butterfly Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 9

$227.88 $232.88

Gold-Plated Sterling Silver University Of Virginia Crest Round Cuff Links, 15MM

Sold out

Gold-Plated Sterling Silver Southern Methodist University Crest Cuff Links, 15MM

Sold out

Genuine Idaho Garnet Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$131.88 $152.88

Engraved Trim Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$179.88 $214.88

Embossed Flowers Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$191.88 $197.88

Elk Oval Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$263.88

Edward Mirell Titanium Cable and 18k Gold Rivets Pendant Necklace, 20"

Sold out

Edward Mirell Titanium Blue Anodized Wide Center 10mm Grooved Band

Sold out

Edward Mirell Black Titanium Blue Anodized Wide Center 10mm Band

Sold out

Edward Mirell Black Titanium and Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 20"

Sold out

Edward Mirell Black Titanium and Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 20"

Sold out

Dove Olive Branch Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$167.88

Diamond Letter 'A' Initial Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 18" (.005 Ct, GH Color, I2 Clarity)

$140.88

Diamond Inset Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (.02 Ct, G-H Color, I1 Clarity)

$479.88

Curved Slide Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (36.75X22.25 MM)

Sold out

Ave 369 Marquise Synthetic Emerald May Birthstone Wrap Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Black Hills Gold

from $229.88

Boulevard Collection Stainless Steel, Black Titanium Memory Cable 10.75mm Band

$347.88 $441.88

Black Epoxy Inlay Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (24X16MM)

$167.88

Adjustable Cable Chain .95mm Sterling Silver, 22''

$64.88 $92.88

Ave 369 6-Stone CZ Dragonfly Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$249.88

3.2 mm Stainless Steel Curb Chain, 18"

from $62.88

14k Yellow Gold, 14k White Crucifix Pendant

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold US Army St. Christopher Medal Pendant (25X19MM)

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold St. John Medal Pendant (21X19MM)

$383.88

14k Yellow Gold St. Anthony Medal Charm (26X19 MM)

$455.88

14k Yellow Gold Round San Juan de Los Lagos Medal (15 MM)

from $275.88

14k Yellow Gold Mother Teresa Medal Pendant (21X19MM)

$467.88

Ave 369 14k Yellow Gold Holy Spirit Dove Medal Round Pendant (24X18MM)

$383.88

14k Yellow Gold Hollow Divino Nino Round Medal Pendant (19X19MM)

$309.88 $404.88

Ave 369 14k Yellow Gold 4-Way Cross Medal Pendant (29x19MM)

$479.88

14k Yellow Gold 2.40mm Diamond-Cut Rope Extender Safety Chain

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold 1.3mm Diamond-Cut Box Chain, Extender Safety Chain, 1.25"

Sold out

14k White Gold Round St. Luke Medal

from $431.88

12k Rose Gold Rose Bud Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold on Black Hills Gold Motif

$311.88

Ave 369 10k Yellow Gold Tree of Life Cross, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

$371.88

10k Yellow Gold Lady of Mount Carmel Framed Enamel Pendant (25.75x25.75 MM)

Sold out

AVE 369 10k Yellow Gold .90 Ct Faceted Onyx Marquise Ring with 12k Green and Rose Gold

$431.88

1.5mm Sterling Silver Solid Cable Necklace Extender or Safety Chain, 3"

Sold out

1 mm Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Diamond Cut Cable Bracelet, 7"

Sold out

Angel Wing Leaf Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold with 12k Green & Rose Black Hills Gold Leaves, 18" Chain – Sentimental Jewelry Gift for Women

$299.88

Ave 369 Black Powder Coat with Gold Trim and Leaves Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$299.88

Cocobolo Wood, Birch Wood, Sterling Silver 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$491.88 $806.88

Cocobolo Wood, Birch Wood, Sterling Silver 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 9.25

$491.88 $806.88

Ave 369 Women's 10k Yellow Gold, Gibeon Meteorite Inlay 3mm Comfort-Fit Wedding Band

from $491.88

Sindora Sleeve with Matte Titanium Overlay 6.5mm Comfort-Fit Ring

from $407.88

Sindora Sleeve with Matte Titanium Overlay 6.5mm Comfort-Fit Ring, Size 5.25

$407.88 $657.88

Peruvian Ipe Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Interchangeable Wedding Ring

$311.88 $969.88

Peruvian Ipe Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Interchangeable Wedding Ring, Size 5.75

$311.88 $969.88

Peruvian Ipe Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Interchangeable Wedding Ring, Size 8

$311.88 $969.88

Peruvian Ipe Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Interchangeable Wedding Ring, Size 13.75

$407.88 $969.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Rose Gold, Sandblasted Titanium 6mm Comfort Fit Band

from $491.88

Rose Gold, Sandblasted Titanium 6mm Comfort Fit Band, Size 4.25

$491.88 $1,457.88

Rose Gold, Sandblasted Titanium 6mm Comfort Fit Band, Size 11

$491.88 $1,457.88

Amboyna Burl Wood 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 11.5

from $347.88

Amboyna Burl Wood 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.25

$347.88 $1,302.88

Amboyna Wood 9mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 10

from $383.88

14k White Gold August CZ Birthstone Ring, Size 3

Sold out

Cocobolo Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 13.25

$455.88 $971.88

Cocobolo Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 10

from $347.88

Redwood, 14k Rose Gold 10mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

from $407.88

Redwood, 14k Rose Gold 10mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5.5

$407.88 $857.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Koa Wood Inlay 12mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring

from $263.88

Buckeye Burl Wood, 14k Yellow Gold Pinstripe 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band, Size 12.5

$443.88 $626.88

Rosewood Box with Brass Clock and Brass Compass (4.25x4.25IN)

$119.88

Ave 369 Created Opal Heart Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Gold Pink and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $239.88

Edward Mirell Titanium Black Cable and Black Spinel with Argentium Sterling Silver Bezel Pendant Necklace, 20"

$359.88 $1,135.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver 1.65 Ct Sky Blue Topaz and Diamond Pendant Necklace 18 Inches (.012 Ctw, HJ, I3)

Sold out

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Dog Tag Pendant

$95.88

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Key Chain

$71.88

Men's Stainless Steel Dad Bracelet 8.75 Inches

$119.88

Ave 369 Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold 1mm Solid Cable Chain Necklace Extender and Safety Chain

from $107.88

Ave 369 'What Would Jesus Do' 14k Yellow Gold Prayer Ring

Sold out

Ave 369 Women's Gibeon Meteorite Inlay 3mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $491.88

Ave 369 'Unblossomed Rose' 14k Yellow Gold Chastity Ring

Sold out

Ave 369 'Jesus I Trust In You' 14k Yellow Gold Prayer Ring

from $251.88

Rhodium-Plated Sterling Silver Amethyst and Diamond Double Hearts Ring in Black Hills Gold

from $215.88

Ruby Redwood Burl 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.5

$275.88 $391.88

Titanium Gypsy-Set CZ 3.75mm Ribbed Comfort-Fit Band

$122.88 $126.88

Redwood, Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10.25

$347.88 $377.88

Men's Titanium Amboyna Burl Wood 10mm Comfort-Fit Band, Interchangeable, Handmade, Size 9.25

$455.88 $482.88

Black Ti Collection Black Titanium Domed Textured Lines 6mm Domed Wedding Band, Size 13

Sold out

Black Ti Collection Black Titanium Flat Laser Patterned 10mm Wedding Band

$309.88 $425.88

Oval Created Emerald Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 6.5

$419.88 $531.88

Pink and Purple Poplar Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 14.75

$395.88 $516.88

Grooved Round Edged 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13

$152.88 $201.88

Brushed Grey Titanium, Black Ti 8mm Beveled Edge Band, Size 10.5

$333.88 $435.88

Titanium Satin Concave 6mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 12.5

$111.88 $116.88

Diamond Starburst Ring, Sterling Silver (.05 Ctw, G-H Color, I1 Clarity), Size 6.75

Sold out

2-Tone Dove Cross Ring, Rhodium-Plated 10k Yellow and White Gold, Size 4.25

Sold out

Titanium Precision Diamond-Cut Design 8mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 10.5

$111.88 $116.88

On sale

Flat Profile Solid Titanium 8mm Comfort-Fit Polished Band, Size 14

$230.88 $301.88

Leaf and Grape Cluster Cocktail Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 6.5

$113.88 $149.88

Casted Collection Titanium and Sterling Silver Inlay 11mm Leaf Two-Tone Band, Size 8

$400.88 $455.88

Red Stingray Leather 5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5.5

$407.88 $532.88

Grey Titanium, Black IP 8mm Wedding Band, Size 9.5

$111.88 $159.88

1 mm Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Diamond Cut Cable Chain, 18"

$383.88 $399.88

14k Rose Gold 3.75mm Comfort-Fit Rope Pattern Band, Size 4.5

Sold out

Army Camouflage 9mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 14.5

$491.88 $589.88

Blue Box Elder Burl Wood 10mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 9

$275.88 $421.88

White Freshwater Cultured Pearl Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver (6.5-7mm) Size 7.75

Sold out

Red and Black Poplar Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 4.25

$395.88 $516.88

Green Box Elder Burl, Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10.5

$335.88 $377.88

Titanium Gypsy-Set CZ 3.75mm Ribbed Comfort-Fit Band Size 11

$122.88 $126.88

Amboyna Burl Wood 10mm Comfort-Fit Flat Titanium Band, Size 7.5

$383.88

Men's Brushed Signet Ring, Continuum Sterling Silver (12mm) Size 12.75

Sold out

Amboyna Burl Wood 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band, Interchangeable, Size 15.75

$463.88 $482.88

Lab Created Blue Spinel September Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$229.88 $399.88

Sapphire, Amethyst, Aquamarine, Citrine, Garnet, Emerald Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 7.5

$311.88

Inverted Grooved 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 6.5

$152.88 $201.88

Satin Titanium 7mm Comfort-Fit Beveled Edge Wedding Band, Size 10.5

$230.88 $301.88

Modern Stack Rings 1mm Comfort Fit Brushed Titanium Band, Size 5.75

$476.88 $496.88

Cherry Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Interchangeable Titanium Wedding Band, Size 9

$415.88 $542.88

Dark Brazilian Rosewood 4.5mm Comfort-Fit Grooved and Sandblast Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5.75

$383.88 $501.88

Midnight Cable Collection Black Titanium, Black Ti Cable, Black Spinel 7mm Band, Size 12

Sold out

Green Box Elder Burl Wood 4mm Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Band, Size 9.75

$335.88 $391.88

Titanium, Yellow IP Edged Gypsy-Set CZ 5mm Flat Comfort-Fit Band

$122.88 $126.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) 8mm Comfort Fit Satin Black Tungsten Band, Size 13

Sold out

Buckeye Burl Wood, Bronze Pinstripe 10mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Ring, Size 4.5

$404.88 $527.88

Ziricote Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 11

$413.88 $540.88

Anodized Collection Black Titanium Patterned Blue Anodized Scrollwork 9mm Wedding Band, Size 9

Sold out

Brushed Titanium 10mm Grooved Comfort-Fit Band, Size 9.5

$111.88 $116.88

Red Grooved Pinstripe 5mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8.5

$284.88 $372.88

Titanium 4mm Comfort-Fit Flat Band, Size 9.5

$111.88 $116.88

Bloodwood with Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 4

$323.88 $501.88

Stainless Steel 2.5mm Bismark Chain, 20"

$89.88 $94.88

Whiskey Barrel Oak Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band, Size 11.5

$479.88 $745.88

Deer Antler 8mm Comfort Fit Dome Titanium Band, Size 5.75

$431.88 $441.88

Diamond-Cut Leaf Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 8

$239.88

Edward Mirell Brushed Titanium Blue Topaz 4mm Wedding Band, Size 10

$206.88 $270.88