Jewelry Under $500

Love Knot Rope Trim Crisscross Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Love Knot Rope Trim Crisscross Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Loss of a Father Sterling Silver Pendant (21X15.20 MM)

Sold out

Loops Leaves and Grapes with Fish Hook Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$439.88 $466.88

Loop Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (36.5x26.25 MM)

Sold out

Little Foliage Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$132.88 $209.88

Linked Hearts Pendant, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Linked Hearts Pendant, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

14k Yellow Gold Linked Hearts Pendant

Sold out

Linked Hearts Pendant, 10k Yellow Gold

$283.88 $355.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (39X25MM)

$409.88 $501.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (28X18MM)

$224.88 $352.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (22X14MM)

$163.88 $257.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (18X12MM)

Sold out

Line Pattern Inlay Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (39X25MM)

$332.88 $521.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (28X18MM)

$227.88 $357.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (22X14MM)

$162.88 $256.88

Line Pattern Inlay Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (18X12MM)

Sold out

Lignum Vitae Wood Overlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Ring

from $229.88

Lignum Vitae Wood 11mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 5

from $259.88

Light Blue CZ Teardrop Ash Holder Necklace, Rhodium Plate Sterling Silver, 18"

Sold out

Light Blue CZ High Polish Bar Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 18"

$196.88 $309.88

Leopardwood Dome 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $279.88

Leopardwood 8mm Comfort-Fit Domed Titanium Band

from $249.88

Leopard Wood 8mm Sandblasted Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$269.88 $406.88

Lemon Quartz Marquise Sterling Silver Necklace, 18"

Sold out

Lemon Quartz Antique Square Sterling Silver Pendant

Sold out

Leaves with Grapes Stud-Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$239.88 $297.88

Leaves and Grapes Slide Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$299.88 $457.88

Leaves and Grapes Slide Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$222.88 $359.88

Leaf Slider Pendant, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$138.88 $219.88

Leaf Slider Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 20"

$279.88 $326.88

Leaf Pendant Slider, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$259.88 $406.88

Leaf Pendant Slider Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 20"

$389.88 $496.88

Leaf Pendant Slider Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$349.88 $412.88

Leaf Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$179.88 $222.88

Leaf on Vine Cuff Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 2.5"

$319.88 $471.88

Leaf Lever Back Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$156.88 $246.88

Leaf Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$239.88 $279.88

Leaf Dangle Hoop Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$409.88 $501.88

Leaf Dangle Earrings Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$159.88 $187.88

Leaf Charm Bead, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$189.88

Leaf Ankle Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 9.25"

$169.88

Leaf and Scrolling Vine Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$149.88

Leaf & Floral Design Bracelet, 14k Yellow Gold, 7"

$295.88 $562.88

Layered Ring with Frosty Leaves, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$209.88

Latin Hollow Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$210.88 $332.88

Latin Hollow Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

Sold out

Latin Hollow Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

Sold out

Latin Cross with Design 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

Sold out

Latin Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant(31X18MM)

Sold out

Latin Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant(26.8X14MM)

$184.88 $291.88

Latin Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant(22.3X12MM)

$249.88

Latin Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Gold Pendant (31.50X20.00 MM)

$469.88 $634.88

Latin Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88

Latin Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant(31X18MM)

$329.88 $389.88

Latin Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant(30X14MM)

$219.88 $275.88

Latin Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant(25.7X12MM)

$152.88 $241.88

Latin Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (42X25MM)

Sold out

Latin Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (31.50X20.00 MM)

$469.88 $632.88

Latin Cross 14k White Gold Pendant

Sold out

Large Raised Arm Crucifix Pendant, 14k Yellow Gold, 14K Rose Gold-Plated (29x22.5MM)

Sold out

Large Heart Locket Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88 $251.88

Large Crucifix 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$242.88 $382.88

Large Crucifix 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$165.88 $261.88

Large 7-Stone Diamond Cluster Christian Cross 14k White Gold Pendant (.10 Ctw) 30.40X16.26MM

$414.88 $651.88

Large 7-Stone Diamond Cluster Christian Cross 14k Rose Gold Pendant (1/10 Ctw) 30.40X16.26MM

Sold out

Lapis Lazuli Inlay 9mm Comfort-Fit Sandblasted Titanium Band

from $439.88

Lapis Lazuli Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$483.88 $757.88

Lapis Lazuli Inlay 6mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$429.88 $635.88

Lapis Lazuli Inlay 3mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$429.88 $757.88

Lapis Lazuli 8mm Titanium Dome Comfort-Fit Band

$483.88 $757.88

On sale

Lapis Lazuli 3mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Slim Profile Band

$429.88 $757.88

Ladies Small 14k White Gold Christian Cross Pendant

Sold out

Lab Created White Spinel April Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Soude Emerald May Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 5.25

$129.88 $147.88

Lab Created Soude Amethyst February Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Ruby Marquise Wrap Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Pink and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

Sold out

Lab Created Ruby July Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 10

$209.88 $222.88

Lab Created Gold Topaz November Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Garnet January Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Emerald Marquise Wrap Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Pink and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$329.88 $401.88

Lab Created Blue Zircon December Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Blue Spinel September Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 5.5

$129.88 $147.88

Lab Created Aquamarine March Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$141.88 $222.88

Lab Created Alexandrite June Birthstone Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, Size 6.25

$129.88 $147.88

Kokopelli Stud Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$289.88

Koa Wood, Titanium Pinstripe 6.5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Band

from $269.88

Koa Wood Pinstripes 7.5mm Comfort Fit Polished Titanium Band

$279.88 $377.88

Koa Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $249.88

Koa Wood Cross Design 8mm Brushed Titanium Comfort-Fit Wedding Ring

from $439.88

Koa Wood 6.5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

from $269.88

Knot Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (34.75x22.75 MM)

$62.88 $101.88

Knot Cross 10K Yellow Gold Pendant (34.75x22.75 MM)

Sold out

Knife Edge Titanium 5mm Comfort-Fit Koa Wood Band

from $319.88

Knife Edge Frosted Titanium 7mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band

$141.88 $222.88

Knife Edge 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

$126.88 $201.88

Kingwood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 7.25

from $319.88

King Wood Inlay 7mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

from $289.88

Key of Love for a Son Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 18"

Sold out

Kera Pattee Cross Cylinder Bead Sterling Silver Charm

$73.88 $116.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Kauri Wood Inlay 6mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

$416.88 $652.88

Kauri Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

from $229.88

Kauri Wood 6mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

from $419.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $189.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size9.25

$162.88 $256.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size8.75

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size7.75

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size7.25

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size7

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size6.5

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size6.25

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size5.75

$114.88 $181.88

June Birthstone Created Alexandrite Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size5.5

$114.88 $181.88

July Birthstone Created Ruby Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $189.88

July Birthstone Created Ruby Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif, Size

$162.88 $256.88

Journey Leaf Pendant, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Journey Leaf Pendant, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Journey Leaf Pendant, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Journey Leaf Pendant, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Journey Leaf Necklace,14k Yellow Gold, 18"

Sold out

Journey Leaf Necklace,14k Rose Gold, 18"

Sold out

Journey Leaf Necklace, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold, 18"

$364.88 $571.88

Journey Heart Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$180.88 $284.88

Journey Footprints Sterling Silver Pendant

Sold out

Journey Footprints 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

$204.88

Journey Footprints 14k White Gold Pendant

$279.88

Journey CZ Journey Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 18" Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 18"

$61.88 $97.88

Jesus Fish Ash Holder Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plate Sterling Silver, 18"

Sold out

Jazz Hands Frog Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$89.88 $115.88

January Birthstone Created Garnet Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

$189.88 $297.88

January Birthstone Created Garnet Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

$162.88 $256.88

Ironwood, Walnut Wood, Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $409.88

Ironwood, Walnut Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 8

from $455.88

Ironwood, Titanium Pinstripe Inlay 9mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

$319.88 $501.88

Ironwood, Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Ring, Size 6

from $269.88

Ironwood, Titanium Pinstripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band, Size 4.5

from $289.88

Ironwood, Celtic Eternity 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 11.25

$449.88 $695.88

Ironwood, 14k Rose Gold 7.5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

from $419.88

Ironwood with Titanium Pinstripe 9mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Parts, Size 10

from $259.88

Ironwood with Ring Armor 9mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13

from $239.88

Ironwood Sleeve with Brushed Titanium Overlay 6mm Comfort Fit Band

from $299.88

Ironwood Matte Titanium 5mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 5.5

$239.88 $375.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Ironwood Inlay, Titanium Pinstripe 5mm Comfort Fit Slender Ring

from $259.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Ironwood Flat Ring 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $219.88

Ironwood Comfort-Fit Ring 6mm Sandblasted Titanium Wedding Band

$359.88 $669.88

Ironwood Burl Tungsten 8mm Comfort-Fit Band, Size 8

$299.88 $471.88

Ironwood Burl Exotic Wood Ring 8mm Comfort-Fit Tungsten Wedding Band, Size 9

$299.88 $471.88

Ironwood Burl 8mm Comfort-Fit Band with Brushed Satin Titanium Overlay

from $339.88

Ironwood 9mm Comfort-Fit Flat Titanium Band, Size 10

from $289.88

Ironwood 7mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10.5

$415.88 $651.88

Ironwood 5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

$319.88 $501.88

Ironwood 5mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Band

$319.88 $501.88

Ironwood 12mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $259.88

Ipe Wood, 14k Yellow Gold Pinstripe 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Ring

$439.88 $754.88

IP- Plated Stainless Steel Polished Black Cuff Links, 10X18MM

Sold out

IP Plated Stainless Steel Polished Textured Blue Round Cuff Links

$79.88 $126.88

Inverted Grooved 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$126.88 $201.88

Intricate Grape Leaf Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$329.88 $484.88

Interlocking Double Heart Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$189.88 $190.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, Sterling Silver, 18"

$69.88 $111.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold, 18"

$406.88 $637.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, 14k Yellow Gold, 18"

$378.88 $472.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, 14k Yellow Gold, 18"

$369.88 $577.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, 14k Rose Gold, 18"

$373.88 $467.88

Interlocking Circle Necklace, 14k Rose Gold, 18"

$405.88 $635.88

Interlocking Beaded Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Interlocking Beaded Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Interlocking Beaded Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Interlocking Beaded Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Interlocked Twin Heart Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$139.88

Interlocked Hearts Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $149.88

Interlocked Hearts Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold, 18"

$149.88

Interlink Twin Heart Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 6.75"

$299.88 $307.88

Interchanging Band: Green Box Elder Burl or Ironwood 9mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band

from $435.88

Interchangeable Wood Ring with Peridot Burl Wood Inlay 8 mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band

from $219.88

Interchangeable Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band , Size 10

from $219.88

Interchangeable Redwood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Brushed Titanium Ring, Size 11.25

from $229.88

Interchangeable Bamboo Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Rings , Size 11

from $399.88

Interchangeable Bamboo Inlay 9mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band, Size 13

from $289.88

Interchangeable Amboyna Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13.5

$425.88 $669.88

INRI Crucifix 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (17X12MM)

$211.88 $330.88

INRI Beveled Crucifix 14k White Gold Pendant (24x16MM)

$386.88 $603.88

Inlay Protestant Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (39X25MM)

$319.88 $501.88

Inlay Protestant Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (28X18MM)

Sold out

Inlay Protestant Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (22X14MM)

$239.88 $257.88

Inlay Protestant Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (18X12MM)

Sold out

Inlay Protestant Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (39X25MM)

$332.88 $521.88

Inlay Protestant Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (28X18MM)

$279.88 $357.88

Inlay Protestant Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (22X14MM)

$269.88

Inlay Protestant Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (18X12MM)

$219.88

Inlay Petal Cross 14k Yellow Gold (22.00X14.00 MM)

$269.88 $331.88

Inlay Passion Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

Sold out

Inlay Passion Cross 14k White Gold Pendant

from $289.88

Inlay Passion Cross 14k White Gold Pendant

from $429.88

Inlay Greek Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (26.50X20.50 MM)

Sold out

Inlay Cross Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 24" (39.00X21.70 MM)

Sold out

Inlay Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (29X19MM)

$49.88 $79.88

Inlay Cross Sterling Silver Nacklace, 24"

$162.88 $257.88

Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (39X25MM)

Sold out