Jewelry Under $500

Ave 369 Black Cuff Bracelet, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

$169.88

Ave 369 Black Cuff Bracelet, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$179.88

Black Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$169.88

Black Cross Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 20"

$139.88 $171.88

Black Cross Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 20"

$108.88 $171.88

Black Cross Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold

Sold out

Black Coated Cross Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

Sold out

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Black Ceramic, Mimetic Meteorite 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

$359.88 $564.88

Black Butterfly Necklace, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$139.88 $159.88

Black Butterfly Earrings, 12k Rose and Green Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$239.88

Black Ash Burl, Titanium Pinstripe Ring, His and Hers Wedding Band Set

$489.88 $782.88

Black Ash Burl, Titanium Pinstripe 6mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$269.88 $377.88

Black Ash Burl Wood, 14K Yellow Gold 6mm Comfort Fit Sandblasted Titanium Band , Size 10

from $489.88

Black Ash Burl Wood, 14k Yellow Gold 5.5mm Comfort Fit Sandblasted Titanium Band

$409.88 $642.88

Black Ash Burl Wood with Titanium Pinstripe 6mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$269.88 $377.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Ring

from $249.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Polished Titanium Band

from $259.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 5mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$219.88 $377.88

Black Ash Burl Wood Inlay 10mm Comfort-Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Black Ash Burl Wood 6mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $219.88

Black Ash Burl Inlay 4mm Comfort Fit Matte Titanium Wedding Band

from $219.88

Black and White Mokume 10mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $369.88

Black and White Diamond Cat and Dog Sterling Silver Necklace, 18" with Charm Pet Collar Tag

Sold out

Black and White CZ Triangle Drop Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Earrings

$231.88 $291.88

Black and White CZ Music Note Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Ear Crawler Earrings

$216.88 $271.88

Black and White CZ Graceful Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Earrings

$214.88 $337.88

Black and White CZ Graceful Pendant Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Necklace, 18"

$172.88 $271.88

Black and White CZ Ear Climber Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Stud Earrings

$208.88 $327.88

Black and White CZ Double Triangle Pendant Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Necklace, 18"

$148.88 $234.88

Black and Red Mokume, Titanium Pinstripe 9mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $339.88

Black and Green Poplar Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$329.88 $516.88

Black and Blue Cobaltium Mokume Gane 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Band

from $399.88

Black Akoya Cultured Pearl Bypass Ring, 14k White Gold (5.50mm) Size 6

$499.88 $622.88

Black Akoya Cultured Pearl 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (6.00MM)

Sold out

Birds Eye Maple with Copper Inlay 8mm Comfort-Fit Brushed Titanium Wedding Band

$259.88 $637.88

Bezel-Set Aquamarine Bar Necklace, Sterling Silver, 16-18"

Sold out

Bezel Set Diamond J Hoop Earrings, Sterling Silver (1/10 Ctw, G-H Color, Clarity I1)

Sold out

Beveled Rectangle Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18''

$159.88

Beveled Passion Flower Cross Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold, 18"

$279.88 $291.88

Beveled Hollow Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (26X17MM)

Sold out

Beveled Edge Sideways Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$84.88 $134.88

On sale

Beveled Edge Profile 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 4

$100.87 $160.88

Beveled Edge Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$84.88 $134.88

Beveled Edge Cross Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 20"

$299.88 $369.88

Beveled Edge Cross Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$199.88 $241.88

Beveled Edge 4mm Comfort Fit 14k White Gold Band

Sold out

Beveled Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (15.5X10MM)

Sold out

Beveled Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (13X08.50 MM)

$209.88

Bethlehem Olive Wood Sleeve and Pinstripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band

from $439.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (Unisex Jewelry) Bethlehem Olive Wood Inlay 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $249.88

Ave 369 'Believe' Text with Butterfly Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$129.88

Ave 369 Beautiful Roses Semi Hoop Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$269.88

Ave 369 Beautiful Rose Flower Pendant Necklace, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$199.88

Beautiful Butterfly Design Bracelet, 14k Yellow Gold, 7"

$222.88 $423.88

Ave 369 Beautiful 3D Rose Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$179.88

Beaded Triple Hoop Earrings, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Triple Hoop Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

$383.88 $601.88

Beaded Triple Hoop Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

$391.88 $614.88

Beaded Triple Hoop Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

$391.88 $612.88

Beaded J-Hoop Earrings, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded J Hoop Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold (12mm)

Sold out

Beaded J Hoop Earrings, Continuum Sterling Silver (12mm)

Sold out

Beaded J Hoop Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold (17mm)

from $353.88

Beaded J Hoop Earrings, 14k Rose Gold (12mm)

from $352.88

Beaded Drop Earrings,14k Yellow Gold

$392.88 $491.88

Beaded Drop Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Beaded Drop Earrings ,Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Dome Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Design 4.4mm Stacking Band, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Cross Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Beaded Cross Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Beaded Cross Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Beaded Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (25.4X17.2 MM)

$201.88 $315.88

Beaded Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (17.5X12.10 MM)

Sold out

Beaded Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (13.5X9.4 MM)

$122.88 $194.88

Beaded Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (25.4X17.2 MM)

$204.88 $321.88

Beaded Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (17.5X12.10 MM)

$147.88 $232.88

Beaded Cross 14k Rose Gold Pendant (25.4X17.2 MM)

Sold out

Beaded Cross 14k Rose Gold Pendant (17.5X12.10 MM)

$147.88 $232.88

Beaded Cross 14k Rose Gold Pendant (13.5X9.4 MM)

$124.88 $196.88

Beaded Criss-Cross Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Criss-Cross Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Beaded Criss-Cross Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Beaded Criss-Cross Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Beaded Circle Stud Earrings, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Circle Stud Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Beaded Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Botonee Cross Sterling Silver Pendant (19.20X8.90 MM)

$62.88 $101.88

Beaded Botonee Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (19.20X8.90 MM)

Sold out

Beaded Botonee Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (19.20X8.90 MM)

$163.88 $257.88

Beaded Botonee Cross 14k Rose Gold Pendant (19.20X8.90 MM)

Sold out

Beaded Bar Earring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Beaded Bar Earring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

$225.88 $354.88

Beaded Bar Earring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Beaded Bar Earring, 14k Rose Gold

$240.88 $377.88

Beaded 1.7mm Stacking Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Beaded 1.7mm Stacking Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Beaded 1.7mm Stacking Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Beadblast Titanium Dome 8mm Comfort-Fit Tulip Wood Band

from $349.88

Beadblast Titanium Dome 6mm Comfort-Fit Tulip Wood Band

$349.88 $547.88

Beadblast Titanium 8mm Comfort Fit Tulip Wood Flat Band

$409.88 $637.88

Beadblast Titanium 6mm Comfort Fit Tulip Wood Flat Band

$429.88 $637.88

Bead-Blast Quilted Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Bead-Blast Quilted Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Bead-Blast Quilted Ring, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Bead-Blast Quilted Ring, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Bead Trim Trefoil Cross Pendant, Sterling Silver

$64.88 $102.88

Bead Trim Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

$386.88 $606.88

Bead Trim Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

$469.88 $589.88

Bead Trim Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Bead Trim Dangle Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Bead Trim Dangle Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

$399.88 $626.88

Bead Trim Curving Ear Climbers, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Bead Trim Curving Ear Climbers, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

$299.88 $337.88

Bead Trim Curving Ear Climbers, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Bead Trim Curving Ear Climbers, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Bass Guitar String, Rowan Wood 8mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $469.88

Barrel Racer Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$139.88 $171.88

Barrel Leaf Charm Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$159.88

Bark Finished, Grooved 9mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

$251.88 $394.88

Bar Chain Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Bangle Cuff Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$299.88 $454.88

Bamboo Zen 2.5mm Sterling Silver Stackable Ring, Size 5.25

Sold out

Bamboo Zen 2.5mm 14k Yellow Gold Stackable Ring, Size 4

Sold out

Bamboo Wood, Sterling Silver 7mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 10

from $439.88

Bamboo Wood Stripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Interchangeable Ring

from $219.88

Bamboo Wood 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Wedding Band, Size 13

from $219.88

Bamboo Inlays 9mm Comfort Fit Interchangeable Titanium Ring, Size 13.75

from $259.88

Bamboo 14k Rose Gold Pinstripe 9mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $379.88

Ave 369 Ball Post Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$189.88

Ave 369 Ball Post Earrings, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$349.88

August Birthstone Stud Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Ave 369 August Birthstone Peridot Stud Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

$329.88

Ave 369 August Birthstone Created Soude Peridot Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $189.88

Ave 369 August Birthstone Created Soude Peridot Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $119.88

Asymmetrical Grape Vine with Leaves Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 10k Green and Rose Gold, 18" to 22"

Sold out

Artists Square and Leaf Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 10k Green and Rose Gold, 18" to 22"

Sold out

Artists Filigree Leaf Pendant Necklace, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver, 10k Rose Gold, 18" to 22"

Sold out

Arrowhead Tie Tack, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$159.88 $251.88

Arrowhead Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 24"

$174.88 $275.88

Arrowhead Bolo Tie, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$243.88 $382.88

Arrowhead Bolo Tie, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$269.88 $382.88

Ave 369 Arrow Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

Sold out

Ave 369 Arrow Edge Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$89.88

Arrow Bypass CZ Ring, Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver

$196.88 $309.88

Army Camouflage 9mm Comfort-Fit Titanium Wedding Band

from $309.88

Arctic Camo 8mm Comfort-Fit Tungsten Band

$299.88 $471.88

Archangel Medal 'St. Michael Medal' Rhodium Plate Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 18"

$131.88

Archangel Medal 'St. Michael Medal' Rhodium Plate Sterling Silver Pendant Necklace, 18"

Sold out

Aquamarine, Citrine, Garnet, Amethyst, Sapphire, Emerald and Blue Sky Topaz Pointed Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$269.88 $291.88

Aquamarine, Citrine, Garnet, Amethyst, Sapphire and Emerald Pointed Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$259.88 $283.88

Aquamarine, Citrine, Garnet and Pink Tourmaline Pointed Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$239.88

Aquamarine Two-Stone Earrings, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Aquamarine Two-Stone Earrings, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Aquamarine Two-Stone Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine Two-Stone Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine Two-Stone Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine Tree Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$249.88 $356.88

Aquamarine Three-Stone Stud Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine Three-Stone Ear Climbers, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Aquamarine Solitaire Rhodium Plate 14k White Gold Pendant Necklace, 16"

$429.88 $567.88

Aquamarine Solitaire 14k Yellow Gold Pendant Necklace, 16"

$459.88 $551.88

Aquamarine Quatrefoil Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Aquamarine J-Hoop Earrings, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine J-Hoop Earrings, 14k Yellow Gold

Sold out

Aquamarine J-Hoop Earrings, 14k Rose Gold

$385.88 $604.88

Aquamarine Inlay Cross Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold Pendant (22.8x11.3MM)

$220.88 $346.88

Aquamarine Inlay Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant (22.8x11.3MM)

Sold out

Aquamarine Beaded Ring, Sterling Silver, Size 6

Sold out

Aquamarine Beaded Ring, Rhodium-Plated 14k White Gold, Size 6.5

Sold out

Aquamarine Beaded Ring, 14k Yellow Gold, Size 6

Sold out

Aquamarine Beaded Ring, 14k Rose Gold, Size 6

Sold out

Aquamarine and Diamond Vintage-Style Ring, Sterling Silver (0.03 Ctw, G-H Color, I1 Clarity)

Sold out

The Men's Jewelry Store (for HER) Aquamarine and Citrine Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$199.88 $300.88

Ave 369 Aquamarine and Citrine Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$199.88

Aquamarine 7-Stone 3.25mm Ring, Sterling Silver

Sold out

Aqua Blue CZ Stud Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Earrings

$112.88 $177.88

The Men's Jewelry Store (for HER) Aqua Blue CZ Mirror Polished Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Eternity Ring

$131.88 $206.88

Aqua Blue CZ Bar Pendant Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Necklace, 18"

$142.88 $225.88

April Birthstone Heart Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88

Ave 369 April Birthstone Created White Spinel Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $189.88

Ave 369 April Birthstone Created White Spinel Bypass Ring, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Silver Motif

from $119.88

Apostles Engraved Cross 14k White Gold Pendant

Sold out

Apostles Cross 14k Yellow Gold Pendant

Sold out

Apostles Cross 14k White Gold Pendant

Sold out

Antler, Oak Wood Pinstripe 8mm Comfort Fit Titanium Band

from $459.88

Ave 369 Antiquing with Beveled Edge Cross Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$229.88

Antiqued, Petite Cross Pendant Necklace, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif, 18"

$189.88

Ave 369 Antiqued with Grape Leaves Band, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $399.88

Antiqued Western Rope Trim Cuff Bracelet, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$349.88

Antiqued Western Boot Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$165.88 $261.88

Ave 369 Antiqued Victorian Fancy Band, Sterling Silver, 12k Rose and Green Gold Black Hills Gold

from $149.88

Ave 369 Antiqued Sunflower Ring, 10k Yellow Gold, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

from $469.88

Antiqued St. Michael Sterling Silver Medal Necklace, 24" (25 MM)

from $71.88

Antiqued Square Stackable 3.9mm Sterling Silver Ring, Size 7

Sold out

Antiqued Semi Hoop Earrings, Sterling Silver, 12k Green and Rose Gold Black Hills Gold Motif

$239.88 $241.88

Antiqued S Scroll Stackable 3.1mm Sterling Silver Ring, Size 7

Sold out

Antiqued Round St. Michael Sterling Silver Medal (22 MM)

from $42.88

Antiqued Round 'Celebration of Life' Ash Holder Necklace, Rhodium Plate Sterling Silver, 18"

Sold out

Antiqued Raised Scroll Design 3.8mm Stackable Sterling Silver Ring, Size 7

Sold out